There aren’t many establishments where you can order a SPAM and Cheez Whiz sandwich — but should you have the hankering, Which Wich? has you covered. This sandwich shop has more than 50 varities, everything from meatloaf to peanut butter and banana.

What I like about this place most is how you order: Just grab one of the paper sacks and use the checklist printed on it to customize your order. On a recent visit there I kept it simple with turkey and avocado on wheat. The service was quick, and the sandwich was delightful — no skimping on the meat, and the hoagie was perfectly toasted. And in fact, all sandwiches come toasted unless you request otherwise.

If you’re in a hurry, you can order online for pickup. And there’s also a handful of shakes, cookies, and breakfast sandwiches, too.